1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
Moderator: VelvetGeorge
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 5:44 pm
1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
Hi,
in the last weeks I had many problems with this build, and finally I solved them using a double pole power switch, to switch both cables from main.
I had the chance to play it just at medium/low volumes, and it's very clean and organic, almost no crunch at all. I love how it sounds on ch 2, both with strat and Les Paul. It's too woofy on ch 1, but I knew that.
Anyway, I have some problems to solve.
1. If I'm playing and switch off the standby switch, the sound becomes lo-fi and scratchy, as it should. The problem is that it lasts forever, the volume doesn't die as it is supposed to do. Even if I turn volume to zero, something it's still audible.
If I switch power switch to off position, the sound come back at full volume for something like 5 seconds, then it dies suddenly with a pop noise.
2. If I turn the three tone pots and presence to 0 it loses much volume. This is normal?
3. Presence pot is only one being a little bit scratchy.
4. if I'm playing on ch 2 and turn volume on ch 1, where nothing is plugged into, I get a very muffled sound. Is it normal that ch1 volume interacts with ch1?
4.b the same happens if I'm plugged into ch2 and turn ch1 volume.
Amps is basically stock. It has a couple of F+T 50+50 filter caps, 33+33 on board. 150uF on first cathode. A split/shared cathode switch (the loud pop if I change it is normal?).
Thanks.
in the last weeks I had many problems with this build, and finally I solved them using a double pole power switch, to switch both cables from main.
I had the chance to play it just at medium/low volumes, and it's very clean and organic, almost no crunch at all. I love how it sounds on ch 2, both with strat and Les Paul. It's too woofy on ch 1, but I knew that.
Anyway, I have some problems to solve.
1. If I'm playing and switch off the standby switch, the sound becomes lo-fi and scratchy, as it should. The problem is that it lasts forever, the volume doesn't die as it is supposed to do. Even if I turn volume to zero, something it's still audible.
If I switch power switch to off position, the sound come back at full volume for something like 5 seconds, then it dies suddenly with a pop noise.
2. If I turn the three tone pots and presence to 0 it loses much volume. This is normal?
3. Presence pot is only one being a little bit scratchy.
4. if I'm playing on ch 2 and turn volume on ch 1, where nothing is plugged into, I get a very muffled sound. Is it normal that ch1 volume interacts with ch1?
4.b the same happens if I'm plugged into ch2 and turn ch1 volume.
Amps is basically stock. It has a couple of F+T 50+50 filter caps, 33+33 on board. 150uF on first cathode. A split/shared cathode switch (the loud pop if I change it is normal?).
Thanks.
- neikeel
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7231
- Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2005 8:31 am
- Location: Suffolk, England
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
Funny things you have been doing to create these noises
May I suggest you post some clear high res pics. Odd that it sounds 'woofy' on channel 1 that should be the brightest and sharpest of the two channels, oh and try a 10uF or max 25uF cap on V1.
Wonder if you have mixed channels with your shared/split cathode switch (you do not say what your other cathode values are?). Yes a pop is quite normal. You can put a 1meg R to ground, that might help. But usually avoid switching when you are playing.
Will wait for pics
May I suggest you post some clear high res pics. Odd that it sounds 'woofy' on channel 1 that should be the brightest and sharpest of the two channels, oh and try a 10uF or max 25uF cap on V1.
Wonder if you have mixed channels with your shared/split cathode switch (you do not say what your other cathode values are?). Yes a pop is quite normal. You can put a 1meg R to ground, that might help. But usually avoid switching when you are playing.
Will wait for pics
Neil
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Aug 20, 2011 4:24 am
- Just the numbers in order: 7
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
1. As it should, except for the residual forever scratch in stby, and the pop at the end of the volume ramp when turning off.
Hmm.. You have something going on in the area of the treble cap/slope area... You built a Fender!
Heh
Hmm.. You have something going on in the area of the treble cap/slope area... You built a Fender!
Heh
not kicking the dead horse
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Aug 20, 2011 4:24 am
- Just the numbers in order: 7
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
OMG you used purple bus wire!
I see the problem. Your PPIMV is not hooked up.
Just kidding. I go look now.
I see the problem. Your PPIMV is not hooked up.
Just kidding. I go look now.
not kicking the dead horse
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Aug 20, 2011 4:24 am
- Just the numbers in order: 7
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
Good news. It all works as it should.
Bad practice all around the dress from the .. from everything. You need to get your input wires down to the deck instead of that stylish waving thing that is half a loop around and over. Look at one of George's amps (or Neil's) for perfection in dress.
All the lead from the pots should dive straight to the deck, route to where they go, then straight up to the junction. Anywhere you have a loop in a power creates a transmitter, any loops in signal are antennas.
The channels do affect each other. Your's will crosstalk more because of lead dress. With the tones at 0 you have around 12db average cut on signal, ballpark.
I'll give it another look when I get a few minutes here, but looks fair as I see it.
Bad practice all around the dress from the .. from everything. You need to get your input wires down to the deck instead of that stylish waving thing that is half a loop around and over. Look at one of George's amps (or Neil's) for perfection in dress.
All the lead from the pots should dive straight to the deck, route to where they go, then straight up to the junction. Anywhere you have a loop in a power creates a transmitter, any loops in signal are antennas.
The channels do affect each other. Your's will crosstalk more because of lead dress. With the tones at 0 you have around 12db average cut on signal, ballpark.
I'll give it another look when I get a few minutes here, but looks fair as I see it.
not kicking the dead horse
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 5:44 pm
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
You made me laugh with the stylish waving thing.
I've a folder in my computer with many guts shot of various plexi, mostly by "boutique" builders. Some are works of art, some don't look that good.
This is the third amp I build, the other two being a couple of SLO, where I had to pay attention to noise since they're high gain
I could do this plexi better than it is, with shorter and straighter leads, but I decided not to just after looking at all this gut shots.
Do you think I have to cut them shorter? The fact that I have no noise or hum isn't a sign that general wiring isn't bad at all?
What about the standby behaviour?
thanks a lot.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Aug 20, 2011 4:24 am
- Just the numbers in order: 7
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
No need to cut, for the most part just use a tool to push the wires to the chassis. Things like that input loopish thing are asking for a parasite. I think somewhere later in the circuit is where signal is jumping in standby and creating the "ecccchhhhh" when you bash on the guitar inmthat mode. Gotta be.
not kicking the dead horse
- toner
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2582
- Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2006 7:57 pm
- Location: Iowa
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
This is caused by the resistor you added across the standby switch. Is that resistor 10k? Are you trying to simulate lower voltage for a "brown sound" there? (if so, that's not a good way to do it)whitewave wrote:1. If I'm playing and switch off the standby switch, the sound becomes lo-fi and scratchy, as it should. The problem is that it lasts forever, the volume doesn't die as it is supposed to do. Even if I turn volume to zero, something it's still audible.
I'm not sure what you are attempting to do there but if you are trying to maintain some plate voltage to prevent "cathode poisoning" when in standby, you need a much larger resistor to reduce the delay in the "scratchy" sound and have no sound once the voltage drops (100k or higher, 2 Watts+).
Some volume rise and a pop noise is typical when switching power off while in play mode (not in standby).whitewave wrote:If I switch power switch to off position, the sound come back at full volume for something like 5 seconds, then it dies suddenly with a pop noise.
Some volume loss is natural, especially with the treble pot, but if you lose all volume, something isn't wired correctly (for a Marshall).whitewave wrote:2. If I turn the three tone pots and presence to 0 it loses much volume. This is normal?
That's normal for the type of presence pot you have.whitewave wrote:3. Presence pot is only one being a little bit scratchy.
Not normal!!! The unused channel's volume pot will affect gain and frequency response a little but you shouldn't get a "muffled sound".whitewave wrote:4. if I'm playing on ch 2 and turn volume on ch 1, where nothing is plugged into, I get a very muffled sound. Is it normal that ch1 volume interacts with ch1?
4.b the same happens if I'm plugged into ch2 and turn ch1 volume.
Loud pop noise is typical with that switch. (I'm not sure how to fix it but Neil's suggestion may work.) Turn the volumes down before switching.whitewave wrote:A split/shared cathode switch (the loud pop if I change it is normal?).
Lift your preamp and PI grid wires (V1-V3, pins 2 and 7) up away from other wires, especially the heaters to reduce noise.
Last, but not least.... purple wire is known to cause serious problems... Good luck!
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Aug 20, 2011 4:24 am
- Just the numbers in order: 7
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
LOL told ya!
I am thinking dress is more than one of he issues, one of those being the crosstalk, no toner? Jist imagining what is there.
I am thinking dress is more than one of he issues, one of those being the crosstalk, no toner? Jist imagining what is there.
not kicking the dead horse
- toner
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2582
- Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2006 7:57 pm
- Location: Iowa
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
The input jack wiring doesn't look that bad, but yeah, who knows what's going on under the board.Reeltarded wrote:...I am thinking dress is more than one of he issues, one of those being the crosstalk, no toner? Jist imagining what is there.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 60
- Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 5:44 pm
Re: 1986 sounds wonderful, but many problems
nothing in particular under the board, the wire just come out of the board the way you see them