Post
by daveweyer » Thu Oct 27, 2016 8:55 pm
As promised, here is a short (sort of) story about a West Coast Wah provided to Jimi.
It was late 1968. It had been a rough year politically for a lot of folks, but it had been a good year economically for West Coast Organ and Amp Service and the Thomas Organ Company.
The Vox division of Thomas Organ was busily designing their new line of amplifiers to be called the Series Ninety, and had geared up for a new Wah Wah pedal which, in order to save money on production and insure more consistency from pedal to pedal, they intended to build in-house. Savvy marketers always, the new pedal was to have an indentation on the very front of the aluminum casting as large as the case could accommodate, to allow the application of a Vox logo, the large lettering could then be seen easily by anyone watching a concert, or any visual media reproduction of a concert, essentially giving Vox a lot of free advertising. The idea followed the same principle as the provision of the theater organ played by Bob Ralston on the Lawrence Welk show, the organ having a highly exaggerated Thomas Organ logo, clearly visible in every shot when the organ was either featured or in the background. To the delight of the Vox higher-ups, the Wah pedal had been very popular, with tens of thousands of units having moved across music dealers’ display counters. One might reasonably argue that it had been Eric Clapton, and then of course Jimi Hendrix, who made the pedal a must-have for every rock musician, and every up and coming hopeful who wanted the musical association with such hugely popular figures in the field of rock music. If you recall seeing the pedal on TV or in film, you will likely associate it with one of these stars, or other mega-acts of the day. Perhaps it was symbiotic, because what would Jimi have done without the Wah pedal?
West Coast Organ and Amplifier in the meantime was growing. They had moved from a small shop hardly a block away from Hollywood High School, to an alley-accessed second level of a building located on Melrose Avenue just off Vine, shared with Fay Peterson’s Golden West Musical Instrument Rentals. The upstairs suite sat directly over a Spanish speaking radio station. The owner of West Coast, Jerry Sanders, had been the assistant national service manager for Thomas and Vox until 1967, when he decided to open his own service business. He had been responsible for overseeing another visual marketing scheme for Vox, the entire 1966 Beatles tour, being on stage every performance to keep the solid state equipment up and running, absolutely.
I had been the Thomas field technical representative in Montana, a job I started in 1963 when I was hired by Ed Schaeffer, the rather prolific local dealer. I was only in high school at the time, but had a radio background and was building amps with along with my childhood friend Bob Hovland every chance I got. Bob and I moved down to LA in ’67 or ’68, Bob taking an engineering job with Thomas under the tutelage of Brad Plunkett, arranged partially through the goodwill of Jack Malmston, one of the organ gurus at the company. Both Bob and I had been introduced to the company hierarchy, including the president Joe Benaron, by Ed Schaeffer, and we had both had a chance to briefly discuss Thomas' plan to buy Jennings Music with Joe at the 1963 NAMM show in Chicago. (Where Bob got to know Jack Malmston and all the other organ gurus along with Stan Cutler the chief engineer) I opined one evening while sitting at a conference party table with Joe Benaron at a giant dinner party hosted by Thomas Organ for its dealers, that the only way to keep guitar players happy would be to build tube amps, and hoped Joe would listen. But he averred, insisting that solid state was more reliable, and that he had a guy, Sava Jacobsen, who could make solid state amps sound exactly like tubes and would design the new equipment, especially the driver transformer. Incidentally, the profit would be much higher on solid state equipment. I can quote Joe with reasonable accuracy on the most important issue to him, “I see three million youngsters out in middle America who see the Beatles on TV and want to own the same equipment as they are playing. There is no way Jennings could make that many tube amplifiers and get them over here for us to distribute out to that sized market in time to take advantage of the trend, besides I have a whole factory full of solid state organ amps already made.”
I certainly understood the concept but there were things about it that bugged me. I didn’t buy, for instance, that these solid state amps would sound just like tubes, having been repairing Thomas Organ amps for a year already at that time, and certainly seeing nothing remotely as alluring in them as I saw in a Jennings AC30, but you can read Sava’s statement on the Vox site where he takes credit for accomplishing that very feat, with an analysis that sounds utterly primitive by today’s standards, hubristic as well. I do have to give credit though for a reasonably good showing for a solid state output system, In fact, if you start with a good tube amp, and then use the output amp module from a Beatle 120 watt solid state head to re-amp the signal through some good Celestion or Jensen speakers, you can create an extraordinarily loud and good sounding concert amp that won't blow up just when you are hitting your stride. Still, it was that in-house hubris that couldn’t see the need for actual tubes in a guitar player’s amplifier which eventually robbed Vox of the very market it was intending to conquer. It also didn’t help that Moog and Arp showed up, giving musicians new and powerful sounds in more or less portable keyboards. The writing for home organs was on the wall, the new market was rock music. But in 1968, the end was a ways off.
When I got to LA I looked in the classifieds of one of the local papers and saw a want add for an organ and amp technician in Hollywood. I showed up for the interview and met Jerry Sanders at the front desk, now in his own business of servicing organs and amps, at a new location, and flush with enough business to have taken on a very delightful secretary named Lynette Faust. I was hired on the spot and given the absolutely wonderful deal of getting half of everything I generated fixing amps, plus a salary of $150 per week. We were now all Thomas Organ extended family, and I had a walk in welcome mat at the company; my best friend Bob was working for Jerry’s best friend Brad Plunkett, and I knew every VIP at the company, at least on a superficial level. Soon, another friend of Jerry’s, Neal Moser, would join us at West Coast, handling the guitars. Neal had been guitar final inspector at Vox, and had become good friends with Jerry there. Every one of us had been associated with Thomas. Neal cut the fret notches in Jimi’s necks for the Foxy Lady thing and installed the Tele neck on the Strat during Hendrix In The West, plus all the other guitar work for Jimi, Neal Young, and the famous and not so famous others of the “summer of love”.
With the internecine relationships between West Coast Organ and Amp and Thomas/Vox, I found I had unprecedented access to engineering expertise, and just as exciting, unbelievable availability of parts. As the Wah pedals came rolling into West Coast for all the various repairs they were known to need, I was able to perform modifications to improve their performance, based on ideas passed down to me directly from Brad Plunkett himself.
Having Brad and Bob to talk things over with and get suggestions was just amazing. Everybody at West Coast thought I was a genius! Brad would say, “just put a .22uf there, add a 47K resistor around the loop, and tell me what happens”. Those little tidbits gave me something most tech guys didn’t have back then. Brad really understood solid state electronics, Bob calls him a genius to this day.
The Wah pedal from the 1968 period has been called the “transition model” by the knowledgable builders out there because it came between the older Clyde McCoy pedal and the new model Vox was tooling up for in late 1968.
Some folks refer to that new design as the “Sepulveda model” because it was made right in Sepulveda CA in the Thomas/Vox factory with outsourced parts and circuit boards. Even though both models are called the V846, the insides are different, and the tone is too, at least marginally. Vox thought the new model sounded the best of them all, even though the variances between pedals were still all over the map. Sharp eared musicians like Jimi Hendrix could hear the difference, and talked about it. I reckoned I might be able to get a little momentum for West Coast by optimizing these pedals, especially for some of the most famous players that used West Coast Organ and Amp Service.
During that period of mods and repairs we had been using 2N3391 transistors as replacements for the 2N3900 units Vox used in their Wah pedals because you could get them with lower noise. Not only that, you could run a power supply of twice the battery voltage and not exceed the breakdown voltage of those transistors. That trick changes the equation considerably, although I am not aware that Jimi ever did that, the battery compartment was too small for one thing. At the time, Vox didn’t even separate their 2N3900s for beta for the pedals because there was not enough profit in them—basically they didn’t care how noisy they were, and of course some were good and some weren’t. Jimi noticed though, and so did a lot of other musicians.
Sometime in early 1969 I was visiting Bob at the Vox engineering department and saw some of the assemblies for the new Vox Wah pedal which was slated to arrive on the market en masse in 1970.
I had an idea that perhaps I could get the components and build one of these to give to Jimi, knowing there would be absolutely nothing on the market like it, and that it would make him the first musician in the world to use one of these in concert. It also seemed like it would be a great reputation builder for West Coast Organ and Amp, and maybe create some increased demand for mods and devices.
To that end I gathered up some of the new components, a pedal casing which had lost or never had its Vox logo on the front, the new circuit board with the Stackpole resistors and the Paktron film capacitors, a newly numbered Allen Bradley pot which Bob or Brad provided from engineering stock, a wiring harness which had been thrown into the parts bin, and a bent bottom plate with the new lettering scheme. These pedal parts were just being accumulated because the production line had not yet been fully integrated within the existing manufacturing process, I think that was all set up later in 1969. To get the rest of the parts I picked through some TDK and other inductors after hours with Bob, and got several to take with me. The 5103 inductor from TDK was really good sounding, but the values were all over the place, and to get the pedal to sound right you needed to be able to get the mh value that suited the rest of the circuit. Everything had 20% tolerances. I tried a 500mh toroid from Triad, several cup inductors from an east coast supplier, and some of the new 5103 TDK plastic enclosed inductors, Thomas had ordered several other values from TDK and would begin using them in their organs and Band Box voicing circuits.
I had only just finished putting the new pedal together when Bob Hovland called and said the Motorola rep had just been in and brought them a new transistor to try (the 2N5089) which had an hfe of up to 1500. Bob recalls the event in this email:
Dave,
When Bob Pekrul the Motorola rep for LA brought in their new low
noise transistors from the 2N5089 family in 1969, these set a new standard
for low noise, since their beta range went up into the thousands on
selected parts. The noise is just about proportional to base
current, so when you put a higher beta part (has to be a low leakage
chip) in, the noise drops in most instances as long as the input
impedance the device sees is in a region where base current is the
major contributor to noise.
If I remember correctly, these are the transistors I brought you one
day after I saw how low the noise was.
Best,
Bob
With the new devices in hand I immediately pulled the 2N3391A transistors out of the Wah pedal and installed the 2N5089 units. The results were great, and the sound of the unit seemed even sharper. I did not even bother to change the base current biasing scheme, but even lower noise could be achieved if the values were worked out for the beta of those units (about 750), and I imagined that I would do that on a future pedal. But for now, it was how quickly I could get this thing to Jimi to try out. Like many techs of the period, I wanted to keep my secrets for possible future business, or even just to create a mystique around the particular item to create musician interest, so I sanded off the small printing on the transistors, making them a mysterious unknown item. Of course, anyone could have reversed engineered the pedal and discovered what I did, but that was part and parcel of the thinking of “garage engineers” back in those days.
Thomas sorted their transistors for hfe and noise distribution, at least on the important items, and put colored dots on the top so assemblers and engineering could tell them apart. When I did the Guitar player article back in 1995 I told them about the purple dots on the top of the transistors, actually orange, green, purple, and even white, all according to current gain/noise.
Art Thompson, the author of the piece had never heard of it, and did not seem to have known what an integral part of the Jimi experience Brad Plunkett had been, in some way he may have learned through me since I worked directly for Jimi and had quite a few stories that had never been offered to the public. I told him to call Brad Plunkett because any story about Jimi’s gear would not be complete without him. I also told him to call Neal Moser, who did Jimi’s guitars and was my partner at West Coast. Art did both, but the relationship with Brad turned into a productive story telling effort over the years, perhaps you have seen the film “The Pedal That Rocked The World”. It seemed to make Brad feel good about the contributions he had made to the rock world, even though his invention was intended for something else entirely.
I mentioned to Art for his story that I had gotten a bunch of speakers for Jimi’s Marshall cabinets from Thomas (they had thousands of Rola Celestian speakers there) and that topic is still debated today on various forums, some still saying the whole Guitar Player article was a fabrication. What can you do, Guitar Player, if it is to be faulted, was only guilty of not providing text for their interviewees to fact check before publishing. I could have straightened out several details in the beginning and saved a lot of needless conjecture over the years.
So the new pedal, at least the West Coast version, used 2N5089 Motorola transistors with a beta of about 750, stock Stackpole resistors which provided 4.192 volts on the collector of Q1, and 3.3 volts on the emitter of Q2 with a new 9 volt battery, Paktron film capacitors for the signal circuitry, and a Kemet 10uf electrolytic bypass capacitor. (I obtained the Kemet 10uf capacitor from Allen Organ Company because of their reputation for using only the longest lasting parts) The inductor was a 530 mh TDK plastic encased coil, and the pot was an AB type J, 120K # 24-5103-3 with a low value exponential taper. (This pot was used in some early Clyde McCoy pedals before it had gotten the Thomas number coding) The jacks were Switchcraft models obtained from Yale Radio, and the 10K output resistor was an IRC, also obtained from Yale Radio. In the production model released in 1970, the jacks were obtained from Carter, and were black in color.
There has been a lot of discussion about the film caps from Paktron, and they have gotten a bad rap from a bunch of guitar players who have encountered Vox gear with a multitude of defective capacitors. Thomas had terrible luck with electrolytic capacitors from Temple, and that is where the horror stories originated, but it was not the Paktron caps which went bad. Even Wah expert Geoffrey Teese admits that the sound of the Paktron film caps is tough to beat, but because of the stories circulating about defective Thomas caps, he had to use Mullards in his reproduction pedals so as not to scare potential customers away. Geoffrey also states that even though he used a different inductor than the TDK 5103 in his own pedal design, that a properly tuned Wah circuit using the 5103 inductor is just so sweet. I note that a number of youtube video demonstrations of pedals using the 5103 inductor show their authors coming to the same conclusion.
So, Jimi had a never- before-seen Wah pedal in 1969, courtesy of the engineering department at Thomas Organ Company, and West Coast Organ and Amp Service. The real discussion of the provision of that pedal revolves around which concerts it appeared in during ’69 and ’70. As I have mentioned before, Jimi had a box full of Wah pedals, and I worked on every one. Likewise, Roger Mayer recalls working on 13 of Jimi’s Wah pedals. There is no reason to think either story is false, because the pedals were notoriously fragile in situations like the concerts Jimi played, and whether simply repaired or modified, they would most likely need service at either coast.
Add to that Jimi’s penchant for trying the latest invention and you have a pretty reasonable story.
I believe Jimi had three pedals which had no Vox logo on the front of the casing. A friend of Roger Mayer’s has told me that one of them was an original Clyde McCoy (you can see the printing on the bottom in some photos, and they did not have the logo on the front anyway), another was a transition model that Roger had modified, and the other one is a mystery (I believe that would be the one I made for him).
I did repair the West Coast pedal along with the equipment we fixed up for the Woodstock concert (the bottom got smashed up a bit and I pounded it back out with a hammer on the anvil of a bench vise, a new battery and cable clamp for the gear), so I know there is a pretty good chance Jimi used the pedal in that show or others of that period. He never mentioned if he absolutely used that particular pedal at Woodstock, but he did say how much he liked it. (We didn’t see much of Jimi for a while after that.) There is the West Coast sticker on that same pedal which was applied at an angle on the bottom, whether or not that was replaced when the pedal came in for repair is also unknown. There is a scratch which goes all the way across the sticker and is also in the paint underneath, at least as far as you can see without removing the sticker.
Now as you will see in the photos, there is a signature on the inside of the casing that says “Jimi ’69”. We have been around and around on whether it is Jimi’s signature or mine or someone else's at West Coast.
I have encouraged Jimi handwriting “experts” to voice their opinions on the matter, and have gotten mixed results, some saying the 6 cannot be his because it is not round enough, but others offering that the J and small m are typical of his style, especially considering that it was a difficult angle at which to print the normal flourishes. He also apparently most always dotted his small i letters, and generally left a small vertical bar on the beginnings of his m, but not always. There have even been claims that the marker pen was not around then, but I checked that out and discovered that the hardened felt tip pens showed up in 1963.
If you look really closely you can see my pencil markings on the circuit board for the transistor lead arrangement, the old transistors had a different basing scheme.
Jimi gave me the pedal in late 1970 after it had been through quite a few concerts. I repaired it again and fully intended to give it back to him as a gift, but it all ended in September, it seemed, just when the show was really getting started. By then he had accumulated plenty of the new production Vox pedals, but none yet with that particular mod from West Coast. Pedals and gear dispersed immediately as everyone involved wanted something out of the deal.
I’m pretty sure there is a quantity of Jimi gear still out there, either being hoarded, or perhaps just worshipped every day by folks who really wanted to touch that phenomenal moment in rock music evolution.
But this is the short story of that particular West Coast modded pedal as close as I can call it without some more memory jogging, luckily I have pictures to share. In fact I have re-taken some of them to get more detail.
I’ll get those up soon.
So, if I have forgotten something, or gotten the sequence wrong in some aspect or another, fire away! Oh, and forgive spell checker weirdness too, I re-read this but it’s easy to miss stuff.
If I can get Adrien or Bill to send me an MP3 audio file of their best raw guitar Jimi licks, I’ll send them through the pedal and Jimi’s amp and then post them on the forum. Maybe someone will recognize a particular sound.